The Soup: Are You the Klutz, the Unlucky, the Mop, or the Change Agent?

This past week I watched Eric Weinstein on Diary of a CEO. If you haven’t watched, or follow the channel, I highly recommend it. You can watch it here. In the interview, Dr. Weinstein brings up an old Yiddish parable of the Schlemiel, Schlimazel, and the Nebbish that I thought was worth discussing as I speak to folks about building their careers. It’s been a long time since I’ve thought about it. Remember Laverne and Shirley, the 1970’s sitcom? While, it was off the air by the time I would have remembered watching it, I definitely remember it in syndication on Nick at Nite. In the theme song, they sang “One, two, three, four, five, six, seven, eight schlemiel, schlimazel, Hasenpfeffer incorporated We’re gonna do it…”, I never thought about it, but as soon as Weinstein mentioned, the flashback hit me and all of a sudden I realized that Laverne and Shirley was funny because they were the Schlemiel and the Schlimazel.

The 4 Archetypes

Let’s start with a scene you know. It’s Friday night. You’re at a ridiculously cramped Italian place with your friends; the kind with checkered tablecloths and chairs that definitely don’t meet fire code. You’ve had a monster of a week, and you’re finally starting to unwind.

A server, young and flustered, rounds the corner with a tray of minestrone. He zigs, you zag.

Hot soup sloshes over the rim.

Your friend Dave, gesturing wildly while telling a story, jerks his elbow back and sends the entire bowl flying. “Whoa, sorry! Totally didn’t see that coming!” Dave, bless his heart, is the Schlemiel—the well-meaning klutz whose good intentions pave a road straight to a soupy mess.

The soup, naturally, lands directly in your lap. You, my friend, are the Schlimazel. You did nothing wrong. You were just sitting there, enjoying your breadsticks, and yet you are the one with a lap full of lukewarm vegetables and a soon-to-be-nasty dry-cleaning bill. You are the victim of someone else’s mess.

Your other friend, Sarah, immediately springs into action. “Oh my god, here!” she says, grabbing every napkin on the table and frantically mopping at your pants. She’s helping, but she’s just cleaning the spill, not fixing the problem. Sarah is the Nebbish; the kind, timid helper who cleans up the mess but avoids the conflict required to prevent the next mess.

Then there’s Maria. She’s been quiet until now. She stands up and takes command. “Okay,” she says with calm authority. To you: “Let’s get some club soda on that right now before it sets.” To the server: “We need a new bowl of soup, a fresh tablecloth, and can you bring the manager over?” To Dave: “Buddy, I love you, but keep the elbows in before you take out a busboy.” And to everyone: “Let’s shift the bread basket away from the edge of the table.”

In 60 seconds, the crisis is managed, the system is improved, and everyone knows what to do. Maria is the Mensch.

These four Yiddish archetypes—the Schlemiel, the Schlimazel, the Nebbish, and the Mensch—are more than just funny characters from old sitcoms. They are a brutally effective shorthand for understanding how we deal with problems, both big and small. They reveal whether we create messes, endure them, clean them, or fix them.

And here’s the kicker: we’ve all been each of these people. You might be a Mensch at work, running your team with flawless processes, but a total Schlemiel at home, where your keys are always “somewhere” and your car is perpetually on empty. The goal isn’t to be perfect; it’s to notice which role you’re playing and consciously choose to be the Mensch more often.

When the “Soup” Costs $440 Million: The Parable in the Real World

This isn’t just about spilled soup. This dynamic plays out in the highest-stakes environments in the world.

The Schlemiel (Good Intentions, Catastrophic Process): In 2012, the trading firm Knight Capital deployed new software. A technician forgot to copy one critical file to one of their servers. The result? The new code battled with old, dead code, unleashing a torrent of uncontrolled, haywire trades. The company lost over $440 million in about 45 minutes. As the SEC’s report later detailed, it wasn’t a malicious act; it was a sloppy process. It was a Schlemiel move on a world-class scale.

The Schlimazel (The Unlucky Victim): In 2017, the global shipping giant Maersk was one of the most efficient companies in the world. But they became a Schlimazel when a piece of Ukrainian accounting software they used was hijacked by a Russian state-sponsored cyberweapon called NotPetya. As detailed in WIRED, the malware tore through Maersk’s global network, costing them an estimated $300 million. They didn’t spill the soup, but they got soaked because their defenses weren’t buffered against a splash from a neighbor.

The Nebbish (Cleaning the Mess, Not Fixing the System): For years, Southwest Airlines was famous for its efficient point-to-point travel. But its internal crew-scheduling technology was aging badly. They knew it. They kept “mopping up” the problems with manual fixes and overtime. Then, during the 2022 holiday season, a massive winter storm hit. The outdated system collapsed entirely, turning a disruption into a full-blown meltdown that cancelled nearly 17,000 flights. As Reuters reported, the company had to apologize and finally commit over $1 billion to fix the core problem they had been patching for years. They were the Nebbish, until they were forced to be the Mensch.

The Mensch (Clean and Change): This is the culture that companies like Google, Amazon, and Etsy strive for. When something goes wrong, they don’t just fix it. They conduct what’s called a “blameless post-mortem.” As Etsy’s engineering blog famously outlined, the goal isn’t to find someone to blame (the Schlemiel). The goal is to analyze the process, find the systemic weakness, and build a guardrail so that specific failure can never happen again. They clean the spill, and then they bolt the table to the floor.

How to Be the Mensch in Your Own Life

You don’t need to run a public company to adopt this mindset. It’s the little things.

1. Tame Your Inner Schlemiel (Stop Spilling): Are you always late? Set a reminder 15 minutes before you need to leave. Is your computer desktop a mess? Make named folders. Ritualize the repeatable parts of your life with checklists.
2. Buffer Your Inner Schlimazel (Prepare for Splashes): Keep a minimum of 3 months reserves in your savings account for unexpected costs. Have a portable battery pack for your phone. Back up your important files to the cloud. Build slack into your schedule.
3. Upgrade Your Inner Nebbish (Help, Then Fix): If you find yourself constantly helping your team with the same last-minute fire drill, don’t just do the work. Say, “I can help get this done today. To prevent this from happening again next Friday, we need to create a simple project checklist. I can lead that on Monday.”
4. Practice the Mensch Mindset: Look at one recurring frustration in your life this week. Ask yourself: What’s the spill? What role am I playing? And what is one, tiny systemic change I can make so this doesn’t happen again?

The point isn’t to never make a mistake. The point is to stop making the same mistake. It’s about taking responsibility not just for cleaning up your messes, but for building a life, a career, and a team where less soup gets spilled in the first place.